For whatever reason, I’ve been re-watching a the majority of Disney lately. The didn’t ache that snow White and also the seven Dwarfs was playing on TV this Thanksgiving; yet also well prior to the holiday ns was immersed in several books around Walt Disney (throughout this piece I"ll be referring to Disney as "they" not "he," i.e. The cumulative studio not the individual man). And I"ve to be renting or borrowing all the old standbys, few of which ns hadn’t seen because childhood. Two films I found myself watching several times – eye White and also the seven Dwarfs and also Sleeping Beauty; I’m not sure why, though the two films do have actually striking similarity (and, as is constantly the case, the similarities offer to highlight major differences as well). Both show up to represent different phases and brand-new directions in the studio’s enterprise, a fashionable topic offered that Disney’s recent attempt to reboot its brand is hitting theaters right around now. I should confess I’m not an especially enticed by Tangled, between the slick CGI (well-servicing a story about robots, but princesses?) and also the shampoo ads. And also what’s v the dopey name-change – were they afraid “Rapunzel” would certainly be too lot of a mouthful? If the studio debuted Pinocchio today, it"d be retitled No Strings Attached through a tie-in to Minwax.

You are watching: Difference between snow white and sleeping beauty


Anyway, earlier to the classics. Speak of Pinocchio, that film remains Disney’s benchmark achievement, with the most interesting storytelling, the richest animation, the busiest frame-filling activity (seriously, the movie never ever stops, whereas both snow White and also Sleeping Beauty have their longueurs). Furthermore, between its unending imaginative clockwork miniworlds in Gepetto"s shop, and also (ironically) the creatively themed "lands" of satisfied Island, Pinocchio is additionally a harbinger the those Magic Kingdoms ~ above the horizon. In spite of these advantages, it"s the two slumbering princess movies I keep coming earlier to. Eye White and also the seven Dwarfs to be the studio’s an initial feature, released every the way back in 1937 (when stated this to relatives watching TV after the meal, every were incredulous, except my grandmother who remembered seeing it when she to be nine). The movie provides a sort of self-discovery top top Disney’s part, as they fight on the tropes, gestures, and also icons i m sorry would come to be touchstones the the studio’s function work. The film opens in an odd, ethereal, rather unfamiliar mode. Countless animated fairy tales begin with a gilded publication opening up, and also Snow White is no exception, however for some reason its book seems older, less an item of twentieth-century nostalgia 보다 a more authentic neck (maybe it’s the usage of a term choose “scullery maid” and also the absence of a contemporary narrator on the soundtrack – the ornate native on the web page speak because that themselves).There is a shimmering, mythical top quality to the early passages in eye White which do it stand the end from the studio’s later on attempts come modernize and familiarize the grisly people tales being adapted (Tangled, i suppose, gift the culmination that this trend). Because that a te Disney had actually been cranking the end Silly Symphonies, and these too had a type of timeless, otherworldly very nice (an interesting comparison to the aggressively contemporary and adult sensibilities the Tex Avery, who would emerge soon after eye White to offer another point of view). However these early on shorts mostly remained rooted in a modern sensibility and a comic easy that eye White originally dispensed with. Meanwhile, the attempts at realism give the human personalities both a more concrete physical presence and also a wispier sense of personality 보다 the dancing flowers or anthropomorphized animals that flickered throughout Disney display screens in early on cartoons. Eye White, Prince Charming, and the huntsman all have a chimerical quality, making lock both haunting and evasive; the Queen has actually a more powerful presence, however she also shimmers prior to us in an uncomfortable fashion that treads follow me the sheet of the Uncanny sink (in which simulated personality appears authentic yet man-made enough to make united state viscerally uncomfortable).
Were the totality film in this key, it would certainly be both more fascinating and less engaging; however that feeling of self-discovery starts right away, as shortly as the huntsman takes snow White out to death her. As he glowers in the background, unsheathing his knife, the princess dances follow me the hill in her familiar blue-red-and-yellow dress and cape (in the first scene she to be wearing the dull colors of a maid) – currently that her iconic existence is acquainted to united state from seventy years of Disney promoting this image, we are already beginning come familiarize and comfort ourselves in this strange setting (obviously in this situation we have an advantage over 1937 audiences, that were seeing her for the very first time). Also so, the huntsman – not just his actions, but his expression – jars us out of any kind of complacency for the time being. Climate the following sequence, through the virtuoso fleeing through the dark wood finishing in the introduction of the friendly, cuddly little animals, provides us a sense of relief. In ~ this point, snow White has wandered out of the Grimm fairy tale and into…well, a Disney movie.The 7 dwarfs, with their distinctive personalities and (pardon the expression) animated presences, are both the biggest concession to modern sensibilities and also the film’s most lasting achievement. With their eyes, and also through the liveliness she takes on in your presence, we deserve to finally start to check out Snow White as a human being being and not simply some sort of mythological figurehead without personality (nonetheless, she remains among the most minimal characters Disney would ever before fashion). No such luck because that Prince Charming, that is nothing an ext than a cardboard cutout transparent – without any kind of dialogue and a fully bland physical presence, his only duty is to inspire schoolgirlish fantasies on snow White’s part, at some point fulfilled in the end when that takes her off to his castle which is precise in the clouds. Poor Dopey doesn’t also get the kiss top top the lips he’s to be gunning for all movie – just another condescending smooch ~ above his outright head as he and also his buddies tide goodbye and their girl waltzes turn off in the arms of a finish stranger. No a happily ever before after because that everyone, apparently.
Few Disney films are as very closely linked in their storytelling as snow White and also Sleeping Beauty, perhaps offered the similarity of the sources themselves (both finish when a princess is awakened from a supernaturally deep sleep through a prince’s kiss). As well as the similar climaxes, both films attribute a young woman who goes off right into the woods where she’s looked ~ by bumbling, short, rotund caretakers (fairies in the instance of resting Beauty), both feature iconic songs around a dreamy romance (“Someday my Prince will Come” vs. “Once upon a Dream”), both have actually a prince sneaking up on the princess and singing and also dancing with her only once prior to they fulfill again at her bedside, both have actually playful, helpful animals as the heroine’s sidekick, and both actors attractively drawn, powerfully charismatic regal women as the villainesses (both of whom have actually cackling ravens together sidekicks, and both the whom space vanquished ~ taking one more form). Top top the various other hand, sleeping Beauty imbues that is hero and also heroine with much more distinct individualities than the vault prince and also princess, which is refresh – Aurora/Briar climbed is a teenager in the warmth of very first love, not just some archetypal girl-woman (Snow White is childish in part ways, yet motherly towards the dwarfs), while Prince Phillip, through virtue that actually having dialogue and also screentime, evolves right into a far much more fleshed-out and also identifiable hero 보다 Charming ever before was.
The most interesting link – and also difference – in between the films is the means both forged brand-new paths because that the studio. Snow White and also the 7 Dwarfs was of food the an initial animated feature for Disney, and also one that the an initial animated features everywhere (certainly the most renowned up come this point); its really existence was something new. While sleeping Beauty was no as overtly groundbreaking, it stood for a radical break v the studio’s previously style. In this light, snow White and also Sleeping Beauty market a fascinating contrast. The previously film is every circles; everything from that is heroine’s face to the landscapes and also architecture i beg your pardon clutter its frames is rounded – whereas resting Beauty is all spicy angles, echoing both gothic spires and the high solution delineated frames of a stained-glass window (the primary colors also pop v a vigor much less visible in snow White’s much more mixed palette). Indigenous a visual standpoint, resting Beauty is among the many gorgeous and exciting things the studio ever did, and it would not be until probably Lilo and also Stitch forty-three years later that Disney would again market such an invigorating break from the residence style.
So is sleeping Beauty the much better film? ns wouldn’t to speak so. The brand-new style can’t lug the material by itself, and also while much of the movie is engaging, that drags in spots. Eye White might not be fairly as dynamic together Pinocchio yet it quiet maintains one unflagging energy and also certainty of purpose at all times; while doing not have the grandeur and striking originality of sleeping Beauty’s drawings (which at time overpower the storytelling) its computer animation is constantly in song with the narrative. As is often the situation with groundbreaking work, snow White’s new is not simply a matter of historic record – this self-consciousness of being “new” actually imbues the occupational itself v a snap and freshness the is essentially unachievable otherwise. Every frame of snow White is exciting and trailblazing – the animators don’t have to worry about repeating themselves or recognize a brand-new “angle,” and it shows. You can’t repeat this type of excitement, and also you certainly can’t purchase it.
That said, I have to close by acknowledging that snow White and the seven Dwarfs is not my favourite animated adaptation of the Grimm Brothers story – the honor belongs come the great 10-minute cartoon native 1933, man by Max Fleischer and starring Betty Boop and also Cab Calloway. The fairy story is sexed up, drugged out, racially coded, and also seriously twisted – or tangled – by modern sensibilities. A contradiction that my previously preference because that the straightahead, unironic storytelling the yore? Perhaps, however to it is in fair if Tangled has actually a rotoscoped ghost/clown contorting his body and also crooning “St. James Infirmary Blues,” perhaps I’d provide it a chance after all.
onNovember 29, 2010

Labels:american classic,animation,disney,double review,fairy tales,monday wild card,movie review/film essay,walt disney


Excellent, MovieMan.A an extremely interesting read.Can i quote a little bit the this because that a not-unrelated piece coming up soon?

November 30, 2010 at 9:17 AM
Joel Bockosaid...

Sure - since you include the next Disney on her countdown won't it is in archetypal, I'm guessing it's no in referral to eye White? can it it is in to the Betty Boop? ns look forward to recognize out!

November 30, 2010 at 9:42 AM
Joel Bockosaid...

Then again, probably it's Lilo and also Stich...either one would be interesting!

November 30, 2010 at 9:44 AM

"Sure - because you implied the next Disney on her countdown won't it is in archetypal, I'm guessing it's no in recommendation to eye White?"Thanks. I think ns may have implied wrongly...this choice is the odd-one-out that the odd-ones-out(!)

November 30, 2010 at 2:25 PM
Tony Dayoubsaid...

It's funny how a quick exposure to Disney deserve to dredge increase a desire to revisit their standard films. I just returned native a holidays to Disney world with the urge to revisit the whole canon (don't recognize if I'll obtain to it).I appreciated your piece, and follow her reasoning. However, possibly it's the formalist in me which finds sleeping BEAUTY the clear front-runner amongst the standard Disney man features. Don't know if you recorded my article earlier this year touting that wondrous visuals however here the is.

December 2, 2010 in ~ 12:17 PM
Joel Bockosaid...

Yes, they acquire us early and also they never shed their hold, the pernicious bastards!Not at every surprised come hear sleeping Beauty is your favorite, of all the Disneys it would have actually my vote together the loveliest come look in ~ (although Bambi, which ns was going come screen-cap last night prior to my computer had trouble v it, offers it a run for that is money, in a naturalistic vein rather than the stylized among SB). Eventually I'll privilege the earlies, which ns feel have a more powerful unity of story and style, and also I discover the fairies a little tiresome as personalities (I don't care all that much for the extended sequence with the fathers either; all in all, resting Beauty appears to have actually a bit more padding than Snow White). The speed of resting Beauty is simply right for the style, but I likewise confess a little bit of a preference for the sewage "business" the Pinocchio. All stated though, sleeping Beauty is most likely my favorite of post-40s Disney (only Lady and also the Tramp, i beg your pardon was always a an individual favorite, could contend with it) and also a top challenger for the best of this extensive period as well.Of course, one can argue the Disney's true masterpiece is not a movie at all but, albeit posthumously, Disney World, which never ever ceases come fascinate me.

December 2, 2010 at 2:00 PM
Joel Bockosaid...

Correction: the write-up asserted the "Sleeping Beauty" was the first Disney in widescreen but this is incorrect: Lady and also the Tramp was absolutely in widescreen together well, and I'm pretty certain Peter Pan to be too.

December 4, 2010 at 2:47 PM
Julie Arsenaultsaid...

Sleeping beauty is my peak favorite Disney film, because that it's artistry and also musical soundtrack

December 5, 2010 in ~ 1:28 PM
Sam Julianosaid...

See more: What Does It Mean When Your Teeth Itch, Why Do You Have Itchy Gums

Wonderful post, and also a reminder of exactly how the earliest Disneys (this, PINOCCHIO, BAMBI and FANTASIA) remin the many extraordinary come this an extremely day. What constantly had be smitten around SNOW WHITE, aside for the compact story and pastel-driven intuitive tapestry, is frank Churchill's operatic score. "One Song" is among the true glories in all of Disney's musical arias.