A criminal defense attorney on the importance of the fifth AmendmentNov 07, 2018 09:18AM𥳻y catalen Maris

In October 2017, George Papadopoulos, a former Trump project advisor, pled guilty to offering false details to commonwealth investigators. Two months later, Michael Flynn, the previous national defense advisor, likewise pled guilty come the exact same charge. Both that the interviews that resulted in these false explanation were offered voluntarily by Papadopoulos and also Flynn after every individual willingly waived his right to remain silent.

You are watching: The tongue is the enemy of the neck

These are two of the many examples the high-profile pleas in the world of criminal defense work. For the person in question, it brings to mind the Arab proverb, “The tongue is the opponent of the neck.” Or, together I personally analyze it, one’s tongue is figuratively the rope with which an separation, personal, instance hangs oneself. The scriptures has a comparable proverb: “Those that guard their tongues keep themselves native calamity.” 
At this time in history, I would certainly argue the the best to continue to be silent (also recognized as the 5th Amendment) is one of the most popular rights protected by the U.S. Constitution. After ~ all, who has not heard law enforcement say come an arrestee on television, “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you to speak can and will it is in held versus you.”
However, in my experience, the ideal to remain silent is the right least likely come be worked out by an individual. As a criminal defense lawyer, that is rarely for me to check out a customer who has actually been charged with a crime and also has not already spoken with legislation enforcement.
To some extent, people being questioned most likely do not recognize the legal minefield through which they room walking. Only 4 years ago, federal law enforcement organ such as the FBI, DEA, and also ATF had policies the prohibited the taping that suspect and also witness interviews. Up until then, at least two agents were compelled to take it handwritten note of the interview, and also those notes would ultimately be summary in typewritten format. The suspect or witness would certainly not get a copy or be given a chance to suggest out errors and also omissions in these notes. This process poses difficulties for the unwary due to the fact that the paper definition of questions and also answers is fully lost. 
An instance of the importance context plays: In the movie “My Cousin Vinny,” bill Gambini and Stan Rothenstein are told that they room being investigated for the shoot of a convenience save clerk in rural Alabama. Immediately, ~ Sheriff Farley tells the young new Yorkers the they room being arrested because of the shooting, Rothenstein, in full confusion, utters: “I shot the clerk? i shot the clerk?” at the trial, Sheriff Farley truthfully testifies the he heard Rothenstein say, “I shot the clerk. I shot the clerk.” Sheriff Farley’s testimony that what he heard Rothenstein say was without any kind of of the paper definition of Rothenstein’s puzzled demeanor and inflection. Without having this necessary context, Rothenstein’s statement took on an altogether different, incorrect meaning; indeed, the conveyed the opposite interpretation of what Farley originally intended.
Additionally, federal agents are ordinary people subject come the same distractions and misperceptions together the remainder of us. In my very own work, I have actually seen instances wherein an agent’s an overview of an interview included far-ranging statements that were incorrect. In one particular case, according to the interview summary, my client allegedly said that the did no attend a particular conference. However, in reality, my client attended that certain conference every solitary year the it was offered. But for part quick activity on our component to get this mistake corrected because that our client, this one concern could have actually potentially become the topic of an allegation the his offering false info to a federal agent. 
As mentioned, interview summaries space never listed to the topic to examine for inaccuracies favor this one. By method of contrast, in every civil lawsuit, witnesses are typically “interviewed” by means of a formal deposition that is spelling word for word by a license is granted court reporter. The deposition is likewise usually audiotaped by the court reporter to ensure the main transcription it is in as exact as possible. Even then, the spelling deposition is submitted to the angry to testimonial for errors.
In might 2014, the department of righteousness realized the the credibility the its agents was enduring from this no-recording policy. Unfortunately, the new policy just “encourages” agents to electronically document interviews. Just “encouraging” agents has not equated to transforming old habits.
Furthermore, federal agents perform not have any kind of special rights or authority when approaching someone in his or she workplace. Yes, it have the right to be intimidating and also overwhelming when an agent reflects up at a place of business, yet the person in question has every right to turn agents away and also ask to speak v them at an additional time as soon as he or she can have a lawyer present. 
The ideal to continue to be silent remains invaluable for each of united state as Americans. There might be a moment when it is entirely suitable to tell her side of the story, but it is never ever a good idea when dealing with two federal agents — or any type of law enforcement because that that issue — that say they just want to speak v you. Too lot is at stake. Particularly when their mistake in listening what you need to say could result in a false details charge.

See more: Where Does Ken Griffey Jr Live Now : Ken Griffey Jr, Ken Griffey Jr

James W. “Jim” Bannister is controlling partner the Bannister, Wyatt & Stalvey. He is recognized by his peers as Lawyer of the Year in the practice area the Criminal Defense: White Collar Crime in best Lawyers in America 2019 and also is one of only 3 lawyers from south Carolina named as a fellow to the American plank of Criminal Defense Lawyers.