Effects of choosing Different inventory Methods

In the video, us saw just how the price of items sold, list cost, and gross margin because that each of the four straightforward costing approaches using perpetual and periodic inventory steps was different. The distinctions for the four methods occur since the company paid different prices for items purchased. No differences would occur if acquisition prices were constant. Since a company’s purchase prices are seldom constant, perform costing technique affects price of products sold, perform cost, gross margin, and also net income. Therefore, companies have to disclose on your financial statements i beg your pardon inventory costing techniques were used.

You are watching: Which inventory costing method results in the lowest net income during a period of rising costs

Advantages and also disadvantages of FIFO The FIFO technique has four major advantages: (1) the is straightforward to apply, (2) the assumed flow of costs corresponds with the typical physical flow of goods, (3) no manipulation of revenue is possible, and also (4) the balance paper amount because that inventory is likely to approximate the present market value. Every the advantages of FIFO occur because when a agency sells goods, the an initial costs it removes from inventory space the earliest unit costs. A company cannot manipulate income by picking which unit come ship due to the fact that the cost of a unit offered is not identified by a serial number. Instead, the cost attached to the unit offered is always the oldest cost. Under FIFO, purchases in ~ the end of the period have no effect on cost of goods sold or network income.

The disadvantages of FIFO incorporate (1) the acknowledgment of record profits and (2) a heavier taxation burden if provided for tax purposes in periods of inflation. We discuss these disadvantages later as benefits of LIFO.

Advantages and disadvantages that LIFO The advantages of the LIFO method are based upon the fact that prices have actually risen nearly constantly because that decades. LIFO supporters claim this upward trend in prices leader to inventory, or paper, earnings if the FIFO an approach is used. During periods the inflation, LIFO reflects the largest cost of goods sold of any kind of of the costing methods due to the fact that the newest prices charged to expense of goods sold are likewise the highest possible costs. The larger the expense of items sold, the smaller the network income.

Those who favor LIFO argue that its use leads to a better matching of costs and also revenues 보다 the other methods. When a agency uses LIFO, the income statement reports both sales revenue and cost of goods sold in current dollars. The resulting gross margin is a far better indicator the management’s capacity to generate income than pistol margin computed making use of FIFO, which may include considerable inventory (paper) profits.

Supporters that FIFO argue that LIFO (1) matches the price of items not sold against revenues, (2) grossly understates inventory, and (3) permits revenue manipulation.

The very first criticism—that LIFO matches the expense of products not sold against revenues—is an extension of the conflict over whether the assumed flow of prices should agree v the physical flow of goods. LIFO supporters complete that that makes more sense to complement current costs against current revenues than come worry around matching costs for the physical flow of goods.

The second criticism—that LIFO grossly understates inventory—is valid. A company may report LIFO inventory in ~ a fraction of its present replacement cost, particularly if the historical costs are indigenous several decades ago. LIFO supporters contend that the raised usefulness the the income statement much more than offsets the negative effect that this undervaluation of inventory on the balance sheet.

The third criticism—that LIFO permits income manipulation—is also valid. Earnings manipulation is feasible under LIFO. For example, assume that management wishes to reduce income. The company could purchase an abnormal lot of items at current high prices near the finish of the present period, through the purpose of selling the products in the following period. Under LIFO, these higher costs are charged to price of goods sold in the current period, leading to a substantial decrease in reported network income. Come obtain higher income, monitoring could delay making the regular amount the purchases until the next duration and thus encompass some the the older, lower prices in price of goods sold.

Tax benefit of LIFO The LIFO method results in the lowest taxable income, and thus the lowest income taxes, as soon as prices space rising. The inner Revenue Service allows companies to usage LIFO for taxes purposes only if they use LIFO for financial report purposes. Suppliers may also report an alternate inventory lot in the notes to their financial statements because that comparison purposes. Since of high inflation during the 1970s, many companies switched indigenous FIFO to LIFO for taxation advantages.

Advantages and also disadvantages of weighted-average as soon as a company uses the weighted-average an approach and prices are rising, its price of goods sold is much less than that derived under LIFO, but much more than that derived under FIFO. List is not as badly understated together under LIFO, however it is not as up-to-date together under FIFO. Weighted-average costing bring away a middle-of-the-road approach. A company can manipulate income under the weighted-average costing method by purchase or failing to buy goods near year-end. However, the averaging procedure reduces the results of to buy or no buying.

The four inventory costing methods, certain identification, FIFO, LIFO, and also weighted-average, involve assumptions about how prices flow through a business. In part instances, assumed expense flows might correspond v the actual physical flow of goods. For example, new meats and also dairy commodities must flow in a FIFO path to stop spoilage losses. In contrast, firms usage coal stack in a heap in a LIFO manner because the newest units purchased are unloaded on optimal of the pile and also sold first. Gasoline hosted in a tank is a great example of an perform that has actually an average physical flow. As the tank is refilled, the new gasoline mixes with the old. Thus, any kind of amount supplied is a mix of the old gas through the new.

Although physical flows are sometimes cited as support for an inventory method, accountants now recognize that an perform method’s assumed price flows need not have to correspond through the yes, really physical circulation of the goods. In fact, good reasons exist for just ignoring physics flows and also choosing one inventory technique based on various other criteria.

Advantages and also disadvantages of details identification providers that usage the specific identification technique of inventory costing state their expense of goods sold and ending inventory in ~ the actual expense of particular units sold and also on hand. Some accountants argue that this method provides the most precise matching of costs and also revenues and is, therefore, the many theoretically sound method. This declare is true for some one-of-a-kind items, such together autos or genuine estate. For these items, use of any kind of other an approach would it seems ~ illogical.

One disadvantage the the specific identification technique is the it patent the manipulation of income. Because that example, assume that a agency bought three identical units that a provided product at different prices. One unit expense $ 2,000, the 2nd cost $ 2,100, and the third cost $ 2,200. The company sold one unit because that $ 2,800. The units are alike, so the customer does not care which of the identical units the firm ships. However, the gross margin on the sale could be either $ 800, $ 700, or $ 600, depending upon which unit the firm ships.

Which is the exactly method? All four methods of perform costing room acceptable; no single method is the just correct method. Various methods are attractive under different conditions.

If a firm wants to match sales revenue with current expense of items sold, that would use LIFO. If a agency seeks to minimize its income taxes in a period of climbing prices, that would additionally use LIFO. Top top the other hand, LIFO frequently charges versus revenues the price of goods not actually sold. Also, LIFO may enable the company to manipulate net revenue by an altering the time of added purchases.

See more: How Tall Is 28 Inches In Feet Conversion Calculator (In To Ft)

The FIFO and certain identification methods an outcome in a more precise matching of historical expense with revenue. However, FIFO can give rise to record profits, while particular identification can give rise to revenue manipulation. The weighted-average method also allows manipulation the income. Only under FIFO is the manipulation the net income not possible.